I’m about to enter major geek territory here (comics and sci-fi TV) so bloody well watch your step. You might stumble into something nerdy.
Both Marvel comics and Battlestar Galactica (BSG) have rejuvenated what I’m calling the “bodysnatchers” narrative (after Invasion of the Bodysnatchers). I don’t know if it has a name already or that it really applies in BSG’s case, but I’m rolling with it. Anyhoo, what it is is a narrative where human beings are revealed to be alien impostors, and the remaining humans in the story are left wondering who they can trust. In BSG, the “bodysnatchers” are the Cylons, a race of advanced machines who evolved and developed the technology to take on the appearance of humans. In Marvel comics, the current Secret Invasion arc sees the shapeshifting Skrull race replacing many of the major and minor superheroes in order to tear them apart from the inside out and eventually take over the world.
I’m kind of loving both right now. The main Secret Invasion book is alright, but it’s the way the infiltration was orchestrated as shown in Mighty Avengers and New Avengers that’s getting me. Brian Michael Bendis, the creative lead on the project, has clearly done his homework. As for BSG, Season 4.5 cannot come out soon enough. I’m pretty sure the ending is going to blow us all away.
However, it’s the ending of these things that usually screw the proverbial pooch.
Marvel has a lot of potential here to make a huge and lasting impact on upcoming stories. However, they also have a convenient way out of unwanted character development, essentially having free rein to change characters however they please by using the excuse “he/she was a skrull all along!” The way I see this working is, once the crossover event is over, the creators will revive whoever the hell they want back in their books and just ignore years of continuity. This has been a beef of mine with comics since I started reading them and I will be severely pissed if everything just resets to zero when all is said and done. Each comic book character has a life of his or her own, shaped by several writers over however many years the character has been around. To undo years of work for shock value or mere convenience is doing a disservice to people who have been following books for a long time and the writers who put a lot of effort to make these characters who they are.
Although, to be fair, I expect much more from Marvel than its main competitor, DC, these days. That whole company is a retcon clusterfuck and probably needed a complete reboot about 8 years ago.
BSG, conversely, has had most of its major character revelations. 11 of the 12 Cylons have been revealed and the success of the finale basically depends on how awesome/lame the pick for the final Cylon is. The great thing about the way BSG handled the bodysnatcher narrative was that the Cylons never really “replaced” so much as “integrated”. Every character on the show who’s been a Cylon has been a Cylon the whole time, so the question of character development getting fucked up is pretty moot. Yeah, to be fair, the “final four” reveal changed a lot, but no so much that I felt cheated by it or that the character development in the episodes prior were at all diminished. If the final Cylon is who I think it is, then I think it’s going to be a rather awesome ending.
I really want both series to succeed. BSG has shown me that a sci-fi can have all the character development, symbolism and depth that you can get from any film, and Secret Invasion is showing me just what is possible with the comic book medium on a grand scale. Both projects have a lot to lose from potential botched endings, and I’m waiting white-knuckled to find out what happens next.
God, so nerdy.