It is a joyous day that brings me quality music, and I gasped (yes, literally gasped) when I saw that the new Parenthetical Girls album had leaked. Their 2006 album Safe As Houses was sent to me by my good friend Aaron and it’s been a favourite of mine since. I’m happy to say that the new album shows a huge step forward for the band, as the influence Xiu Xiu’s Jamie Stewart has had seems to be waning a little bit in favour of bolder sonic ventures. The buzzing synths that set the tone for the previous LP have been replaced with a full-on Modern Opera/Contemporary classical mix on the new Entanglements, and hot damn is it ever good.
One thing that remains intact on Entanglements, though, is a narrative thread that binds the album together. Safe As Houses told the story of a dancer whose tryst with a young man and subsequent pregnancy turn the album’s title into a cruel irony, as even the dancer’s own body works to break her, and no amount of maternal connection can repair the damage:
L-O-V-E scratched your name into me
F-A-C-E and its traces of me
Curls ’round your cheeks, Christ, you looked just like me
When you took nine months to destroy my body. (“I Was The Dancer”)
Much of the album is told in retrospect, first from the perspective of the mother, then that of the daughter once the mother lies down on some train tracks and allows a train to trisect her , but the mother’s obsession with her own body and subsequent miscarriages (especially in “Oh Daughter/Disaster”) and her eventual rejection of her body through suicide (“The Weight She Fell Under”) prevents the daughter from gaining any real comfort, and only finds solace when lying on the graves of her dead brothers (“Stolen Children”). To me, this narrative shows the danger of labelling a woman as “ruined” due to a pregnancy out of wedlock, and how that “ruin” is inherited through the shame brought on by the concept of illegitimacy. A woman’s worth is “ruined” by allowing herself a sexual encounter, and because she’s absorbed this narrative and stereotype, the transformation her body undergoes is revolting to her, and her resentment carries on through the daughter that dared to grow inside of her. This is all told rather melodramatically on the album, but with the tone of the music, it works splendidly. The constant buzz of the synths anchor the album in melancholy while the falsetto male vocals telling this first-person female narrative adds a strange, strained edge to the sound that really reflects the twisting of the daughter’s psyche. Really, a male voice is perfect, as it “talks over” the female narrative and reminds us where the root of the problem supposedly lies.
Entanglements takes a more divorced look at the “ruin” of the female protagonist. The focus is less on the physical destruction of the woman and moreso on the social, emotional and psychological level. I think this album is a huge step up over the story on Safe As Houses because the female character is far more complex, and culpable. The grandiose string and flute arrangements on the Rogers & Hammerstein-esque “Four Words” match the breathless abandon of the female character as she is enraptured by thoughts of love. Her ruin comes at the hands of her own lust, as she, a 25-year-old, leads her object of affection, a 14-year-old boy, to his “coming of age” (“Unmentionables”). The narrative spirals from there, as the woman battles her shame and anger in confrontations with her parents and the rest of society, and eventually she unravels in the disturbing “The Windmills of Your Mind”. This song messes me up on so many levels, as Zac Pennington’s vocals list off a set of similes and metaphors for the woman’s mental collapse in way reminiscent of Maria listing off her favourite things in The Sound of Music. It’s eerie and it’s awesome.
While I do think that the complete and utter ruin of a woman as a result of pregnancy is an incredibly cynical view and tends to peg these women as victims, I can’t help but admire the craftsmanship of both albums, especially Entanglements. Yes, they are extreme examples, but if you consider anorexia and bulimia’s soaring popularity and the slut-shaming that still goes on in discourse surrounding abortion, these two stories really don’t seem that far off. A cautionary tale, perhaps, of what conservatism and ridiculous expectations of physicality and decorum can do to women, and a reminder that we’re swinging back in a dangerous direction.
Neither of these albums are easy listens, but I find them to be incredibly rewarding musically and lyrically. If you can find them, give them a listen. You won’t regret it.